
I’ve been making pickles for years and years at this point. There are almost always some zucchini, red onion or carrot and daikon pickles lurking in the fridge, so it seems a little crazy that I hadn’t tried making cucumber pickles until this year. Arguably the most common pickle of them all! I suppose it makes sense that I gravitated to more unique varieties you can’t buy at the supermarket. But lately I’ve been on a mission to make more things from scratch and stop buying products that are easy, affordable and often just better when homemade. It was really only a matter of time before I tackled the classic cucumber pickle. But of course, I’m putting my own spin on it. And so these Bourbon Dill Pickles were born.
This recipe took a couple of attempts to get right. The first batch smelled incredible – the brine was literally making my mouth water – but after a few days in the fridge, the flavour was surprisingly flat. It needed more of a vinegar punch and um, double the bourbon. So I went back to the drawing board, tweaked the recipe, and tested it a few more times until I landed on my absolute favourite version. The result is a pickle that sits somewhere in between a sweet bread and butter pickle and a classic crisp dill pickle, with just enough bourbon to add a subtle depth of flavour.

What you need to make Bourbon Dill Pickles
Cucumbers – Unfortunately I did not plant cucumbers in time for a harvest this year, and so these are not homegrown. But these Lebanese cucumbers were still in season and extremely affordable when I made this recipe. I also got to use my crinkle cut knife, which is 100% optional, but why does crinkle cut everything magically taste better?
Vinegar – Vinegar is of course the key ingredient in making pickles! It’s a preservative and adds that distinctive brine flavour. I used both white and apple cider vinegar in these pickles. White vinegar gives a clean, sharp flavour and the apple cider vinegar (made from fermented juice) adds a fruity flavour. You can also experiment with malt vinegar if you like, which I think would work well with the bourbon flavour.

Salt – Another absolutely critical ingredient that you can’t leave out. Salt is kind of magical and has several functions in a pickle recipe. It’s a preservative that inhibits bad bacteria growth, but encourages the good bacteria in fermented recipes. It’s a flavour enhancer while also drawing water out of vegetables to ensure they stay crisp. No one likes a soggy pickle! Fine grain white salt is the best to use as other varieties (like Himalayan pink salt) can have other trace minerals that can colour or cloud the brine. This is a refrigerator pickle recipe that isn’t fermented so the vinegar is the primary preservative, but the salt is still super important for flavour and texture.
White sugar – Important for balancing out the intense flavours of vinegar and salt in a pickle brine. Some recipes don’t use it but because this one is inspired by bread and butter pickles, I wanted a some sweetness in the flavour profile.
Mustard seeds – These are the small seeds from the mustard plant, which are available in yellow, brown and black. Many pickle recipes use yellow mustard seeds, which are the easiest to find at the supermarket. They add a distinctive tangy flavour and are widely used for pickles and savoury preserves as they have natural anti-microbial properties. They also plump up in the brine and add a nice texture as well.

Dill – There is something about the scent of fresh dill that just makes my mouth water!! The entire plant is edible and sometimes the seeds are used. I have used the fronds to add that lovely distinctive flavour to my pickles. If you have some dill leftover after this recipe, you should try My Famous Potato Salad. A few of these pickles finely chopped and stirred through the dressing would seriously be so good.
Bourbon – My not so secret ingredient, seeing as it’s in the recipe name and all! The bourbon adds a really delicious something-something that balances really well with all the other ingredients. My biggest tip is to use a bourbon that you already love the flavour of. I used Maker’s Mark because that’s my favourite and what I had on hand. You could experiment with other types of whisky if you like. If you prefer to leave it out, that’s fine too, but it will have an impact the flavour profile.
Optional flavours – If you like, you could add some chilli, garlic cloves or thinly sliced onion. Other spices such as peppercorns, coriander, cumin, dill or celery seeds amp up the flavour even more! All are great options so play around with it!

One thing I learned while I was recipe testing is that the brine needs to taste almost too strong when it’s first made. Once the cucumbers absorb the liquid, the flavour mellows out considerably. While you can technically eat these pickles after 24 hours, they’re much better after 3-5 days once the flavours have mingled. I think they’re at their best after a week in the fridge. These are not a water-bathed shelf stable pickle, so they do have to remain refrigerated. If stored correctly, they will last in the fridge for a couple of months.
And so, I guess cucumber pickles are now added to the list of things I no longer buy! As much as I love wandering around the farmers’ markets and admiring all the beautiful jars of artisan pickles, they can get pretty pricey. Sometimes upwards of $15 a jar! These homemade Bourbon Dill Pickles are every bit as delicious and a little but unique. Plus, if you make a batch when cucumbers are in season, then they are also incredibly affordable too.

Of course, you can use these babies anywhere you’d use regular pickles – on burgers, sandwiches, big mac tacos, potato salad, or in those viral charcuterie nachos. Yeah, those are definitely on my list of things to try next time I invite the girls over! I think these sweet-tangy pickles would make the most epic Cubano, but they’re equally good eaten straight from the jar while standing in front of the fridge… Hey, as pickle lovers, we’ve all been there, right?!
Related Post: Small Batch Green Tomato Chutney


Bourbon Dill Pickles
These homemade Bourbon Dill Pickles are crisp, tangy, slightly sweet and packed with fresh dill flavour. Easy to make and far better than store-bought!
Ingredients
- 750 g cucumbers, thinly sliced (crinkle cut optional!)
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/2 cup white vinegar
- 1 cup apple cider vinegar
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 2 tablespoons salt
- 2 teaspoons mustard seeds
- 1/4 – 1/3 cup bourbon (60-80ml)
- Fresh dill
Instructions
- To make the pickles, first sterilise your jars by submerging them in boiling water in saucepan. Carefully remove them with tongs and Wash jars, metal lids and bottles in hot, soapy water. Rinse thoroughly. Boil in a large pot of water for 10-15 minutes. Remove with tongs. Dry upside down on a clean towel or in a low oven (about 120°C/250°F) for 10-15 minutes until completely dry. Remove carefully with oven mits or a tea towel as the glass is very hot.
- Wash your cucumbers and pat dry with paper towels. Carefully slice them. You can use a mandolin if you like thin pickles, but I used a crinkle cut knife and just went slowly to try and get them as even as possible. Set aside for now.
- To make the brine, place water, white vinegar, apple cider vinegar, sugar, salt, mustard seeds and bourbon into a medium saucepan over medium heat. Stir until the sugar and salt are dissolved and the mixture comes to a boil. Cook for 2-5 minutes and then remove from the heat. Allow to cool.
- Layer the sliced cucumber and fresh dill into jars, making sure to pack them in well. Pour the cooled brine over the cucumbers, pressing them down to submerge. Seal the jars and place in the fridge. The pickles will be ready in 3-7 days.































































